Just another damn group blog!
You know there are warning signs for just about everything. A cold is creeping up on ya, your throat gets that little itch in the back of the throat. The flu, yeah, you feel like you got in a bar fight you did NOT win at all.
It’s the same when you are writing in the wrong scene. It’s harder to pinpoint in first person, because there’s no way you’re in the wrong POV. So here’s a short list I’ve thought up. Oh, and you should be warned I’m using every cliche known to man. (yeah, like that one.)
1. It just feels wrong. It may not feel wrong like you may be kissing a relative wrong, but it’s one of those same gut feelings.
2. There are days where writing can be harder than pulling out teeth with whiskey and pliers, but if you give the scene enough play time it’ll pick up. But if you are on the third day of writing said scene…
A. Ok, it shouldn’t take three days to write a short, quick scene that has a place in the story, and has a goal. It’s pretty much being stubborn until you breakthrough.
B. I repeat, three days on the same scene?
C. You never break through even after writing it for three days.
3. You’re characters have gone from talking about the weather to an awkward silence. How is that possible in a novel? Well, it is if you are in the wrong scene.
4. In your character’s own monologue they are wondering, “What am I doing here?”
5. If you smarten up and go back to the tried and true test of whether or not you have a scene AND the results say you’ve got nothing…
You’re in the wrong scene, stupid. Not you, but me, because I’ve been writing on this scene since Saturday night. It has just now hit me I’m in the wrong scene. Couldn’t figure out why I couldn’t get past it. So, now I’m behind on my own NaNo goal. Sigh.
How do you know when you are in the wrong scene?
Dennie ~
November 9th, 2009 at 2:07 pm
for me, it’s the delete key. When I have re-written the sentence four different ways and can’t get into or out of the scene then I know it’s not meshing well.
or
I write a sentence and write {add more here} … if I do that though, I guess I haven’t really written the scene
MelissaB
November 9th, 2009 at 3:23 pm
The beloved delete key. I didn’t list it, because you know I’m hoarding every word I write with NaNo.
But, yes, delete is my friend.
Amie Stuart
November 9th, 2009 at 3:52 pm
Wrapping up edits on first 150 or so pages of current wip and while I don’t think I had “wrong scenes” I did move stuff around in chapter one so that what I felt was more important was moved to the forefront while less important/secondary stuff was moved back.
Considering this proposal has gone out to, and been rejected by, 5 editors, I’m cringing a bit in part because there was quite a bit of … extraneous stuff…that I cut purely for the sake of pacing. WTF? was I thinking?
I also got a chance to beef up the motivation/goals/conflict in two *very* important scenes. I KNEW they didn’t work/felt lame!
On the downside my H/h have now been apart for 78 pages
MelissaB
November 9th, 2009 at 5:31 pm
A scene in the wrong place falls under the same umbrella for me. When the reader gets that information at the moment it falls flat, but I think it comes more from a revising standpoint as you stated. To me it’s an easier fix. Not that it’s EASY, just easier than hitting your head on the wall.
Amie Stuart
November 9th, 2009 at 6:03 pm
agreed but I’m still shaking my head at some of the crap I cut!
Raine
November 9th, 2009 at 9:04 pm
Ok, I’m gonna plead stupid and say I have no idea what you’re talking about, and yes, I’m sure it’s because I’m feeling really dense…sorry!
Tanya
November 10th, 2009 at 5:45 pm
I’m having the same problem with my YA, but it’s not that it’s the wrong scene, it’s that I’m in the wrong mind frame. I can’t find my character’s voice because I’m so far into another character’s voice in yet another book that I guess I just have to wait until it comes to me. Nothing worse than trying to force something that isn’t there. The kicker is, the book is all plotted out. I’m just not there mentally.