August 26, 2008
Rules of the road … Piggy backing
. . . on what I wrote last week, I have still been thinking: Rules. Are they neccessary? Needed? Important?
I think they are to a degree. Sure you can break them. But the thing is, you still have to know the rules in order to break them.
Driving home the other night, some SOB shot out in front of me and I had to lay on the brakes and the horn because the dumb f*&#*er apparently didn’t know what the red octagonal sign in front of him meant. My mind flashed to my 13-y-o and all the talks about “when you take driver’s ed” and how he would understand some of the road nuances once he learned the rules. If he then chooses to ignore them he has to face the consequences that come with it–like say the red and blue flashy lights that raced after the SOB . . . hehehe.
If you don’t take driver’s ed, you may follow some rules, but you will also break rules, even if by accident. You will see other drivers doing certain things and you will follow their lead, so to speak, and use your common sense as to how and where the appropriate roadways, directions or even parking spaces are. But you may not neccessarily know why these things are important–like turning your tires the correct direction when parking on a hill–trees are not very forgiving to bumpers once that baby picks up speed!
Same goes for writing. You may happen to do some things correctly–common sense is a wonderful thing, but some of the “rules” per se, are particular nuances of writing such a POV/head-hopping, show don’t tell, even something as simple as “filter” words (knew, thought, saw, figured). But you have to know what is what BEFORE you can actually break it. Shoot even something as simple as formatting can be a nightmare if someone doesn’t know to double-space and to use fonts that are readable–my first typed WIP was single spaced and I found the “funnest” font I could–OMG!
Then I learned the rules.
Side note: POV is truly my biggest pet-peeve, mainly because when I joined a critique group years ago, it was the very first thing I was called out on. I was all over the place w/ my POV. Once I understood how dizzying it could be to jump from one person to the other and back and back, I learned how to write scenes from one person, do a page break and go to the next character.
Writing rules are a good jumping off point I think. Many, many people when they hear you’re a writer say, “I want to write a books some day.” (because we all know it is SOOOOO easy) I often tell them, that’s great, read up in the genre you’re interested in and make sure to get really craft books to learn what’s what.
But at the end of the day, the only true, steadfast rule for writers is: The story must be good. If you have a good story/stroy telling ability the other things are easy to fix.



Rules are meant to be broken, but you have to know the right way to break them in order to be successful. See there are even rules for breaking the rules.
The story must be good. If you have a good story/stroy telling ability the other things are easy to fix.
Even if you have to learn the hard way.
See there are even rules for breaking the rules
And people wonder why writers are crazy…
Great post.
My favorite writer excuse when the break the rules is “well, Nora does it.” Yeah, but she does it well and she knows the rules to start with.
There is a reason for the rules. They help us craft a good story. Sometimes the best book is trapped in a web of poor execution. But like you say, if there is a good story there, a writer can fix it. But they need to appreciate that writing is a craft, ergo it is learned. The rules are there to help us write a better story, not torture us as writers.
Tanya ~ My mother was a huge rule breaker so I learned at the feet of a radical woman :-)
And people wonder why writers are crazy
Raine ~ NO JOKE!
“well, Nora does it.”
exactly
The rules are there to help us write a better story, not torture us as writers
LOL. Yep. I met this writer once (a dude, and No, not a romance writer) his WIP was, I kid you not, 400,000 words. As a crit group we tried to impress upon him he needed to trim it down. Weed out some of the unneeded. WELL…. he quit the group mid-meeting and to my knowledge never sold that book.
>>Yeah, but she does it well and she knows the rules to start with.
And um she’s been writing like 30 years. that does tend to give one some leeway