May 23, 2008
Clueless
I have a confession to make.
I don’t have much of a clue.
This won’t come as a surprise to some of you. :razz: But I thought I might as well be honest about it.
There is a marked absence of something in my blog posts, both here and on my own blog, that I see quite a bit of elsewhere.
I do very little in the way of writing advice. Suggestions. Recommendations. How-to posts. Ways to get published. And there’s a very good reason for that.
I don’t have a clue.
Does that sound like a strange confession from someone who professes to be a writer? Yeah, well, it sounds odd to me too.
When I was younger, I gave violin lessons to the children of my friends. No problem. In step-by-step detail it wasn’t hard to teach how to do this, how to play that, how this effect was produced, and what results they could expect. But being technically proficient doesn’t make you a great violinist. It’s a certain unknown quality, a feeling for the music, an affinity for the instrument that makes one exceptional.
A bit of the same with art. I learned a few techniques, taught myself to handle some of the materials, and could probably make suggestions on applying them to a drawing or painting. But that won’t make that painting good, possibly not even interesting. It’s the artist’s own unique vision that makes the work extraordinary.
I’m a little in awe of authors who have it down to a fine science. They can run down the GMAC at the drop of a hat. Tick off the differences between romance/romantica/erotica/women’s fiction/mainstream/scifi/urban fantasy in the blink of an eye. Know exactly where the black moment/sex should fall in the story well in advance. What to cut, how to hook, how to dissect, and how to keep from going overboard.
(And no, the fishing metaphors hadn’t occurred to me until I wrote them, lol).
It must make the writing a lot easier. But it doesn’t make it yours.
Learning craft is one thing.
Mastering your craft is something else.



“I don’t have a clue.”
Makes two.
I’m with you.
Mastering your craft is something else.
I think that is it in a nutshell… you can parrott stuff but it doesn’t make it unique or neccessarily interesting. I think the heart of what you put into it is 75% of the creativity.
Me three. ‘Common knowledge’ ain’t all that common, and doesn’t always apply. Personal experience/opinioin is a whole ‘nother matter.
Count me clueless. I’m not sure if writing with someone else’s template would get me published, but I know it would kill off any desire I had to write.
Hey, I feel like this is directed at me, Raine.
Lol. Well, I’m just self-centered. Now that’s a confession.
But I can agree in a way. Learning craft doesn’t help you if you don’t know your weak points. I’m all for craft workshops, blog posts (because I just wrote three this week.), because I do know it can help to a certain extent. Where I think these types of post (workshops) go off the train tracks is making it seem this is the only way to write. It’s also the reason I found the workshops at RWA wonderful. The speaker always said, either in the beginning or the end of the session “this is my way, it doesn’t have to be yours.” That’s paraphrased of course.
Or who said it best,(La Nora) “If anyone says you HAVE to write this or that way–tell them to f%*# off.” Paraphrased of course.
I’m with you.
Good to have ya, Bernita.
you can parrott stuff but it doesn’t make it unique or neccessarily interesting.
On the mark, Dennie.
‘Common knowledge’ ain’t all that common, and doesn’t always apply.
Exactly!
I’m not sure if writing with someone else’s template would get me published, but I know it would kill off any desire I had to write.
Good point, Bernard.
I mean, if it isn’t “yours”, what’s the point?
Oh, wait, I forgot…it’s for all the money we make…
Hey, I feel like this is directed at me, Raine.
Oh no, no dear. If this was directed at you, I would’ve posted it on your site.
Or who said it best,(La Nora) “If anyone says you HAVE to write this or that way–tell them to f%*# off.”
I feel ya…I feel this way about teaching/doing classes. I mean beyond a query letter WTF do I have to teach anyone?
Oh no, no dear. If this was directed at you, I would’ve posted it on your site. LMAO. I do say disagree in the comments.