May 1, 2008
BAD Writer!!!!
A few years ago, an agent blogger posted a jaw-dropping list of e-query faux pas she’d encountered.
I couldn’t help but feel sympathy. I mean, agents get the same nonsense in unbelievable amounts day in and day out. Personally? Something like that would drive me batshit crazy. Talk about Groundhog Day! While the list was pretty standard fare, a couple of items were simply outrageous. And here I’d thought I’d seen it all.
Check out this little snippet:
-Titles that make no sense
- Huge word counts on genre or YA novels (that have a limited word count - if you did your research)
- Dear Sir or Madame
- Dear Editor !?!?
- Will you publish my novel (no)
- Not putting your contact information on the page (duh)
- Not telling me what the book is about
- Telling me more about your graduate work than your writing- Dropping names of colleges/professions in the first line (who gives a crap?)
- Telling me that you are uniquely qualified to write a novel (everyone is)
- This is the next… (add anything here)
- attaching files to an email that I didn’t ask for
- Asking me if, when I [say] “Mail this to me” I mean [U.S.] mail. (I do)
- Requesting any sort of deposit for your manuscript (!?)
…
- Assume that if I send a rejection, that it was, in fact, on purpose and not a “huge mistake” because you “know we are meant to work together.” (heeby jeebies)
- When I say I’m interest[ed] in Middle Eastern/Persian books - I don’t mean terrorist novels.
Okay, I’ll fess up. I actually did ONE of the above many moons ago, but don’t ask which one ’cause I’m not telling!
So how about you? Reaching back to your newby days, have you ever committed any of these cardinal sins? Or are you guilty of something even more egregious, something that’s not even listed up there? Come on. Fess up. I promise I won’t poke fun at you.
NOT!



I’m guilty of not trying to get an agent for fear of not only rejection, but making a faux pas.
none of those… but oh I am sure I had a few. I sent many a query out before I knew “the rules” and bam, rejection after rejection. I did eventually sell the books–so it wasn’t me
P.S. I think I found a query in a reference book and pretty much dropped my stuff in so in my mind it was the way it was supposed to be, but oh so not me. I think that’s the key thing–be yourself. If you’re funny in your query but the book has no personality… or vice-a-versa
sorry coffee hasn’t kicked in yet, too much thinking…….but you get the point . . . . . I hope
Huge word counts, and not knowing what the word ‘erotic’ meant in erotic romance. Thanks to blogging, I have found out 200,000 word manuscripts by unknown authors do not garner publishing attention, and erotic means EROTIC. :)
A co-author and I once offered an agent a Virginia ham and use of our cabana boy, Fernando, in exchange for an update on the status of our query.
She did respond.
Nope. None of these. Not saying I never made a misstep, but by the time I got around to querying, I’d been online for awhile, in particularly hanging on the eharl messageboards where editors/pubs/newbies were all very generous with tips/advice.
Ha, I’ve been agent searching lately so I’m sure I’ve made more than a few of my own mistakes. The only one glaring in my mind is when I used a different e-mail addy. This particular e-mail eats all the format. I noticed it, but you know I’m kind of slow. So, it never crossed my mind to double check the first page excerpt to make sure it had quotation marks. I checked my sent box and no it did not have quotation marks.
So imagine this:
I need to read you cards, Shelise said.
Okay, but why? I shifted….
I dont think I did but I was very anal about getting it RIGHT. Like freakishly so, then I started not caring about the rules so much.
RAINE I forgot about that!!!!!!
Luckily she’s got quit ea sense of of humor